The answer to the question of whether to choose pension drawdown or an annuity depends on many factors. These include retirement age, total assets, state pension entitlement, attitude to risk, long-term care costs and legacy objectives. Retirement age is particularly important, because annuity rates vary significantly with age.
The scenarios below use the EvolveMyRetirement® model and optimiser to compare alternative retirement-income strategies under a common set of assumptions. These include pension drawdown, annuitisation and an unconstrained optimisation approach.
The outputs shown are illustrative modelling results and should not be interpreted as recommendations or financial advice.
Common Assumptions
- Single male
- Age 60
- State pension of £12,500 per year
- Mortgage-free home worth £350,000
- Cash savings £20,000
- Essential spending: £15,000 per year
- Discretionary spending may be increased following strong performance, or reduced following weak performance
- Pension savings: £500,000
- No other investments
- Medium risk tolerance
- Medium legacy importance
- Inflation: 3% per year
- Long-term care £50,000 per year if required; start date modelled stochastically
- Annuitisation: pension assets are used first; non-pension assets may be used if needed to achieve the target level of guaranteed income
- Home equity available as a contingency resource
Scenario 1: Pension drawdown only
Generated strategy:
- Initial discretionary spending: £11,800 per year
- Annuitisation: Never
Projected outcomes:
- Probability of success: 96.3%
- Median legacy: £511,534
- Probability of home equity release: 27.6%
Scenario 2: Buy annuity and take full tax-free lump sum
Generated strategy:
- Initial discretionary spending: £11,000 per year
- Immediate annuitisation: £375,000
- Projected initial annuity income: £17,775 per year
- Annual annuity increase: 3% fixed
Projected outcomes:
- Probability of success: 97.7%
- Median legacy: £286,926
- Probability of home equity release: 76.9%
Scenario 3: Buy annuity to cover 100% of spending
Generated strategy:
- Initial discretionary spending: £13,200 per year
- Immediate annuitisation: £321,514
- Projected initial annuity income: £15,243 per year
- Annual annuity increase: 3% fixed
Projected outcomes:
- Probability of success: 97.5%
- Median legacy: £406,237
- Probability of home equity release: 33.0%
Scenario 4: Unconstrained optimisation
Generated strategy:
- Initial discretionary spending: £13,700 per year
- Annuitisation in year 2: £451,868 (subject to future circumstances)
- Projected initial annuity income: £22,137 per year
- Annual annuity increase: 3% fixed
Projected outcomes:
- Probability of success: 98.2%
- Median legacy: £297,347
- Probability of home equity release: 72.4%
Key Observations
Under the stated assumptions, no single strategy was superior on every measure. Each approach involved different trade-offs between spending, security, legacy and reliance on housing wealth.
The pension drawdown strategy produced the highest projected legacy (£511,534) and the lowest probability of home-equity release (27.6%), but also the lowest discretionary spending (£11,800 per year) and the lowest probability of success (96.3%).
The scenario involving immediate withdrawal of the full tax-free lump sum produced the highest probability of home-equity release (76.9%), the lowest projected legacy (£286,926) and the lowest level of discretionary spending (£11,000 per year) of the strategies considered.
The strategy that purchased sufficient annuity income to cover current spending requirements occupied a middle ground between the drawdown-only and optimised approaches. Under the stated assumptions, it supported higher spending and a higher probability of success than drawdown alone, whilst preserving a larger projected legacy than the unconstrained optimisation strategy.
The unconstrained optimisation strategy produced the highest discretionary spending (£13,700 per year) and the highest probability of success (98.2%). However, these improvements were achieved at the expense of a lower projected legacy and a greater reliance on housing wealth than in the drawdown-only scenario.
The optimiser did not favour either pure drawdown or immediate annuitisation. Instead, it deferred a substantial annuity purchase until year 2, subject to future circumstances. This retained flexibility in the early years of retirement while preserving the option of securing a higher level of guaranteed income later.
These examples were generated using a common set of assumptions to allow the effect of strategy choice to be compared directly. In practice, retirement outcomes are also influenced by factors such as retirement age, pension savings, spending requirements, risk tolerance, legacy objectives, care provision, state pension entitlement, housing wealth and investment performance.
The EvolveMyRetirement® model supports a much wider range of inputs and assumptions than those used here. The results shown are illustrative modelling outputs and should not be interpreted as recommended actions or financial advice.